Just received my non-OEM Black Jack 'scuttles' for my R57s. First impressions, they look just as good as the OEMs and installed easily enough with the same quality fit. I went with these non-OEMs as two of my Black Jack emblems (same side of course) fell out of the OEM carrier. So figured I would go with the cheaper one-piece untis this time around vs. another trip to the dealership. Even with the exchange and shipping (I am in Toronto), seems like a more reasonable price point (inserts alone are C$180+13% tax here). I did see one comment around fading so time will tell I suppose. 5 stars for now and great service from OutMotoring as well. Thanks.