The Roadster I just purchased is black & I find that I prefer to replace the chrome with black. These are about the only replacement side scuttles in black I could find. I know there is limited replacement parts in all black so there are few choices to offer. However this one just looks cheap. The plastic just doesn't look like it fits on the car. Perhaps because it is dull as opposed to the piano black Mini uses currently. This is the only all black replacement I have found but think I may try another way to get the side scuttle's chrome covered.